I'm always searching for different mascaras and I always end up with this one for 15 years now. Obviously, the result depends on the type of eyelashes you have. I want a natural result, and even with my already thick lashes, it really enhances them even when I wear it without eyeliner. Yes, it smudges a bit if you wear it for hours and it's hot, but still, I prefer it over the waterproof one as it doesn't seem to have the same effect.

Real disappointment from Maybelline, it doesn't make any difference to the eyelashes. I have to put at least 3 coats. Also, it dries out very easily.

I wouldn't buy it again. Very light result. Even for the morning, I prefer others that with 1-2 applications make the eyelashes intense. This one requires you to spend 5 minutes to show something.

The first mascara I ever tried, and after years I bought it again. I wonder why it took me so long to buy it again?! With a thin layer, you get a natural result, with 2 it looks very nice, with 3 it reaches another level. I don't think there is a better value for money. Yes, it does initially release a lot of product and it's not user-friendly, but after about 5 uses, it's perfect.

After the first uses, the result improves a lot. However, the brush gets tangled quite a bit.

If you are not familiar with this specific mascara, you will definitely get smudged! I have found a way to avoid it and I am not bothered anymore! It clumps the lashes together, giving them a very dense look. I personally like this intense result it gives. If it gets even a little bit into the eye... it stings excessively! The big downside is that within 1 hour of application, the lashes lose the curl and density they had with the initial application of the mascara and it's like you have applied a regular mascara. It doesn't hold up! That really bothers me! Other than that, it is wonderful!

I didn't like it at all, I think you need very long and dense eyelashes on your own for it to do what it claims. And of course, I'm not sure about this because I haven't seen it.

No matter how many mascaras I have tried from my sister, who changes them frequently, I insist on this one because the result doesn't weigh down my gaze and looks natural! Definitely not the ideal choice for someone looking for a dramatic result...

I bought it for 9€ at HC and it's not worth it. It sticks to the eyelashes and forcefully lifts them after three passes. I have tried better and cheaper ones. The only advantage it has is that it lasts for hours.

Good morning mascara, easy to use. It doesn't smudge, it just doesn't give a very intense result for the evening!

The lashes need work to appear thick and curled (I use a branded brush in combination with this mascara). Excellent product value for money

It didn't work properly for me at all! I was expecting a more dramatic result, but all it did was make my eyelashes a little darker! That's all!

Cheap mascara with excellent results.
I have not used expensive mascaras to have a comparison. What is certain is that it thickens, lengthens, and separates the lashes and has great lasting power without smudging.

Very good mascara and at an excellent price. It does a better job than other branded ones I have tried and spent a fortune on.

It was the first mascara I tried when I started wearing makeup at a young age. Now, even though I have tried many expensive ones, I have ended up with this one again! The best and at a very good price!

I have tried many mascaras. This one has a good price, provides a complex result (density, length) and is easily removable. Satisfied enough to buy it again.

While it is a good mascara in terms of volume and length, it made my eyes sting and my contact lenses fogged up the whole time.

In terms of value for money, there are better options. Its separation is terrible and it clumps. I wouldn't buy it again.

The best mascara I have ever tried. It makes the eyelashes HUGE, gives perfect volume, separates them perfectly, and gives a lot of length. I love it

At the price it is currently available, it is the most value for money mascara! It is one of the good ones from Maybelline, separates satisfactorily, gives enough volume, and has decent longevity compared to others in the same price range. For everyday use, it is very good, I recommend it!

I believe that it is the best in its category, with a very good price for its quality, it does not clump and makes the eyelashes huge!!!

The best mascara I have ever used! I have tried much more expensive ones, without giving the same result. Affordable and effective!