I will give it 3 stars because while my cat devours the classic Purina Pro Gastrointestinal in pouches in seconds, she doesn't seem to care much for this one. Obviously, you can tell that there is something different based on the price of one and the other, regardless of whether they are from the same company and series. Maybe it will sit better with another cat, so give it a try and see if it eats it eagerly. Otherwise, stick to the classic pouches with chicken and salmon.