I have had them for a year now..
I have been through rain and nothing has passed through.
The motorcycle (bmw g650gs) fell on my foot and only the shoes were slightly injured (do not try it, surely luck was on my side, the ankle protector worked, as well as the shoe leather in contact with the ground)
I highly recommend them for their price.

I have been wearing them for 3 years and they have only minimal wear, nothing beyond the normal. The seams and fabric are intact.
I haven't had the chance to get them wet to test how waterproof they are and how long they can hold up before getting completely soaked.
They are comfortable, both on the bike and while walking. They are not too stiff and allow for all movements. They have ankle protection, at the front and at the heel.
Definitely recommended.
Edit, 05/13/24:
They are almost 5 years in my possession, and they have now started to fray in 2-3 seams, at the points where they touch the bike and rub against it.
I still stand by the 5 stars, comfortable (for up to all day), good brake feel and gear selector, indeed waterproof (in ~2 hours of rain nothing got through, only a little that ran from the cuff straight into the shoe), and I consider them to ventilate adequately. I would easily buy them again, but I will probably go for some boots with more protection for the shin.
Edit, 08/20/24:
I purchased a second pair 2 months ago, this time in brown. Much nicer color than the black, same material although the brown is a bit shinier. Very satisfied. The use I make is not daily, just walks on the weekends. I believe that with daily use they will have half or even less lifespan.

Very comfortable. I wear it daily. How long they will last remains to be seen.
Update. They didn't last. Ripped at the back above the heel on both shoes from everyday walking at work. So I imagine if you only have them for motorcycle rides, they will be okay

Very comfortable for everyday use and if it's not tied on top, you can walk without any annoyances. It seems to be of very good quality and so far it hasn't presented me with anything. Recommended

It is very comfortable.
A little heavy of course, but if we consider the safety in case of a fall as well as the protection from water, then it is worth it.
I highly recommend it for everyday use, as it does what it says and at an affordable price.