I didn't use it much, I struggled to apply it on the eyelid.
I didn't have time, it dried very quickly.
And the quantity has shrunk

The best thing...
Whether for personal or professional use...

I use this specific eyeliner as follows: I take a small amount with the spatula and place it in a mixing palette so that I don't have the product open for too long. It is very important to quickly close the lid for this product to last. This way, the product remains soft as when you bought it. Proper use of the product helps achieve the desired result.

It is very easy to apply.

The most important thing? It doesn't smudge easily no matter what you do. Mascara may come off, foundation may come off, lipstick may come off, but this one doesn't. When it's time to remove it, I have even experimented, I even pour water to see if it smudges, but only the mascara comes off. It takes a lot of effort to remove it from your eyes in the end... you need to find a product that suits you to remove this specific product... I use a Nivea eye makeup remover.

One of the best gel eyeliners, easy to use. Once it dries on the eye, it stays there no matter what you do and it has amazing performance. Definitely requires a little more time for application. But it has a more stable and long-lasting result

From the moment I opened it, it was dry. I tried to use it multiple times but I couldn't effectively use it except for two times, and even then, it took a lot of effort. I even put it in hot water to melt it as suggested on the internet. Nothing changed. Unfortunately, it was a waste of money.