I give it two stars because although it is supposed to be waterproof, it can only withstand about ten minutes of rain. After that, they get wet and water easily seeps into the inside of the glove. They are quite bulky and you have to take them off to answer a call or find something small at the kiosk, for example. They have also torn in some places between the fingers (I have had them for a month). Their main advantage is that they do not let the cold pass through at all and keep the hands quite warm.