I consider it much more practical than the classic collar that restricts visibility and makes it difficult for the dog to eat and drink water. This one is like a small inflatable life jacket that goes around the neck and has Velcro on the edges. It is soft and prevents the dog from scratching its head and the rest of its body. The only thing that won't suit him is during sleep because it is inflatable and keeps his head elevated, so it will take some time for him to get used to it and get comfortable.