As pacifiers, they matched us perfectly. They were the only ones that the little one liked as a baby. And despite trying others of all ages, we continued with these. Perfect quality. And out of all the pacifiers (about 20), only one broke. My only negative is that the size 18+ is quite big compared to the others. It's a big jump from the previous category. I would say that for a girl, at least, this pacifier is more like a 24+.