Without having much experience with motorcycle gloves, I would say that they are not as warm as I would like and not as comfortable.

100% winter gloves. Even at 10 degrees, I felt my hands slightly sweating.
The fit for me, wearing a large size, is perfect on every finger and they feel soft and secure.
For waterproofing, they will be tested when I have the opportunity.
edit: The waterproofing is good. Not perfect, meaning they will let water in during a heavy rainstorm, but the hands will not freeze due to the inner lining.

A year ago I had bought the AGVpro Storm H2O Dry-Tex for some reason, but from the first test on the motorcycle, they didn't fit me well, so I replaced them with the Wagner ones.
So far, no issues, they do what they promise, and you don't feel cold or get wet.
The only annoying thing, as with most gloves, is that if your hand/palm gets a little wet, you will struggle to put them on compared to when they are completely dry.