First of all, I clarify that I am referring to the gray packaging. My eyelashes are very weak and straight. No matter what mascara I use (especially if it is volumizing), it's like I haven't applied anything. With this one, they really look very nice. Firstly, they appear long, separated, and slightly lifted. It has a very thin brush, which helps it spread without smudging the upper eyelid. I would prefer it to be waterproof or at least have a little more durability. At least it doesn't leave black smudges under the eye like others do after hours. So far, I haven't had any smudging. It is value for money!

Indifferent.. it doesn't do any of the things I expected.. for a natural and soft morning look, yes, maybe it does, but otherwise, it's a no from me. I gave it two or three chances, it didn't perform and I threw it away.

Very poor quality mascara, it doesn't separate the eyelashes, it doesn't lift them, and it doesn't give any volume. Overall, it's not worth it at all, I definitely wouldn't buy it again.