The best mascara I have tried (and I have tried countless). Impressive length and irresistible gaze. The only small negative is that after an hour, 1-2 fibers fall under the eyes, but it's no big deal!

I bought this mascara hoping that it has fibers in it, but really Loreal has disappointed me lately. The fiber did not help with volume and length, it just clumped my eyelashes, very disappointing.

My favorite mascara. I have bought it many times, and I still choose it! Intense result with one layer of primer and one layer of mascara. For a more evening look, with another layer, the lashes become like fake ones. I haven't found anything comparable.

I bought this mascara as a continuation of the previous false lash superstar. The first tube is also mascara, not primer. The result is more "natural" compared to the superstar, but still quite intense. I consider it an "evening" mascara. It dries faster than previous double mascaras from L'oreal. I always smudge when applying mascara (any brand) on the eyelid, so I don't have an opinion. But as for smudging after hours under the eyes, I haven't noticed anything like that, even in hot/sweaty conditions.

I had a complete disappointment, I hadn't tried a double mascara that I used to like for a long time. This new one is really terrible, it clumps and you need to use a lash comb afterwards